governance/resolutions/20140617-defcore-capabilities-scoring.rst
Doug Hellmann 7aeee9d9eb Propose scores for DefCore capabilities
This is the set of changes to the original DefCore capabilities scores.

Change-Id: I9613b4e08d246818a892a92261accfac7815f045
2014-07-08 15:48:41 -04:00

127 lines
7.5 KiB
ReStructuredText

=========================================
2014-06-17 DefCore Capabilities Scoring
=========================================
The DefCore team has put together a scorecard_ combining many criteria
to evaluate which capabilities_ of OpenStack should be considered
core. They have asked the TC to help fill in the "Aligns with
Technical Direction" section, replacing the score in each cell with
either ``0`` (for "not needed") or ``1`` (for "required").
The table below includes the three columns from the "Aligns with
Technical Direction" of the original scorecard:
TC Future Direction
Does the Technical Committee plan to continue supporting this
feature?
Complete
Is the feature currently implemented and fully
working?
Stable
Is the API for the feature stable enough to support over a long
period?
..
The table below reproduces the "Aligns with Technical Direction"
section of the spreadsheet as it stands on 2014-06-17, based on
``defcore.csv``. A follow-up changeset will modify this resolution
to reflect the scores of the TC (separate patches will make it
easier to discuss the changes from the original values).
The ``0.5`` values are placeholders for the "undecided" scores the
DefCore committee needs us to resolve.
The other ``1`` and ``0`` scores were decided by the DefCore
committee, but as these are technical questions they are also up for
review. We should focus on filling in the missing values first, and
may want a second pass to update the other values.
The blank fields are for capabilities that won't be included based
on other criteria, so we can score them but don't have to during
this pass.
===== ================================= ===================== ========== ========
Row Candidate Capabilities TC Future Direction Complete Stable
===== ================================= ===================== ========== ========
4 compute-servers 1 1 1
5 volume 1 1 1
6 compute-volume 1 1 1
7 compute-quotas 1 1 1
8 compute-flavors 1 1 1
9 images-v1 1 1 1
10 compute-auth 1 1 1
11 images-v2 1 1 1
12 objectstore-object 1 1 1
13 compute-keypairs 1 1 1
14 compute-servers-metadata 1 1 1
15 objectstore-container 1 1 1
16 volume-snapshots 1 1 1
17 compute-images 0 1 1
18 compute-floating-ips 1 1 1
19 compute-instance-actions 1 1 1
20 compute-security-groups 1 1 1
21 compute-image-metadata 0 1 1
22 objectstore-container-quota 1 1 1
23 compute-virtual-interfaces 1 1 0
24 objectstore-container-acl 0 1 1
25 objectstore-acct-services 0 1 1
26 objectstore-container-staticweb 0 1 1
27 <identity-non-admin-roles> 1 1 0
28 compute-usage 0 1 1
29 compute-limits 1 1 1
30 networks-extensions 1 1 1
31 networks-l2 1 0 0
32 compute-ext-disk-config 0 1 0
33 networks-l3 1 0 0
34 compute-live-migration 1 0 0
35 compute-servers-personality 0 1 1
36 networks-floating-ips 1 0 0
37 networks-security-groups 1 0 0
38 networks-lbaas 1 0 0
39 orch-stacks 0 0 0
40 compute-multiple-create 1 1 1
41 networks-vpn 1 0 0
42 compute-attach-interface 0 0 0
43 networks-quotas 1 0 0
44 compute-auth-v3 1 0 0
45 compute-volume-proxy 0
46 compute-volume-ebs 0
47 compute-console-log 1 0 0
48 identity-admin-v3-roles 1 0 0
49 identity-admin-v3-endpoints 1 0 0
50 identity-admin-v3-credentials 1 0 0
51 identity-admin-v3-domains 1 0 0
52 identity-admin-v3-policies 1 0 0
53 identity-admin-v3-users 1 0 0
54 identity-admin-v3-services 1 0 0
55 identity-admin-v3-tokens 1 0 0
56 identity-admin-v3-projects 1 0 0
57 volume-multi-backend 1 1 1
58 identity-admin-users 0 1 1
59 identity-admin-roles 1 1 1
60 compute-admin-aggregates 1 1 1
61 objectstore-quotas 1 1 1
62 compute-admin-servers-pause 1 1 1
63 compute-admin-servers-suspend 1 1 1
64 identity-admin-tenants 0 1 0
65 compute-admin-avail-zone 0 1 1
66 identity-admin-services 1 1 1
67 volume-extra-specs 1 1 1
68 compute-admin-flavors 1 1 1
69 compute-admin-server 1 1 1
70 compute-admin-services 1 1 1
71 compute-admin-fixed-ips 1 0 1
72 compute-admin-quota 1 1 1
73 compute-admin-hypervisor 1 1 1
74 compute-admin-hosts 1 1 1
===== ================================= ===================== ========== ========
.. _scorecard: https://docs.google.com/a/dreamhost.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Av62KoL8f9kAdFo4V1ZLUFM0OHlrRnFpQUkxSHJ5QWc&usp=drive_web#gid=6
.. _capabilities: https://github.com/stackforge/refstack/tree/master/defcore/havana