swift/doc/source/development_guidelines.rst
Samuel Merritt 728b4ba140 Add checksum to object extended attributes
Currently, our integrity checking for objects is pretty weak when it
comes to object metadata. If the extended attributes on a .data or
.meta file get corrupted in such a way that we can still unpickle it,
we don't have anything that detects that.

This could be especially bad with encrypted etags; if the encrypted
etag (X-Object-Sysmeta-Crypto-Etag or whatever it is) gets some bits
flipped, then we'll cheerfully decrypt the cipherjunk into plainjunk,
then send it to the client. Net effect is that the client sees a GET
response with an ETag that doesn't match the MD5 of the object *and*
Swift has no way of detecting and quarantining this object.

Note that, with an unencrypted object, if the ETag metadatum gets
mangled, then the object will be quarantined by the object server or
auditor, whichever notices first.

As part of this commit, I also ripped out some mocking of
getxattr/setxattr in tests. It appears to be there to allow unit tests
to run on systems where /tmp doesn't support xattrs. However, since
the mock is keyed off of inode number and inode numbers get re-used,
there's lots of leakage between different test runs. On a real FS,
unlinking a file and then creating a new one of the same name will
also reset the xattrs; this isn't the case with the mock.

The mock was pretty old; Ubuntu 12.04 and up all support xattrs in
/tmp, and recent Red Hat / CentOS releases do too. The xattr mock was
added in 2011; maybe it was to support Ubuntu Lucid Lynx?

Bonus: now you can pause a test with the debugger, inspect its files
in /tmp, and actually see the xattrs along with the data.

Since this patch now uses a real filesystem for testing filesystem
operations, tests are skipped if the underlying filesystem does not
support setting xattrs (eg tmpfs or more than 4k of xattrs on ext4).

References to "/tmp" have been replaced with calls to
tempfile.gettempdir(). This will allow setting the TMPDIR envvar in
test setup and getting an XFS filesystem instead of ext4 or tmpfs.

THIS PATCH SIGNIFICANTLY CHANGES TESTING ENVIRONMENTS

With this patch, every test environment will require TMPDIR to be
using a filesystem that supports at least 4k of extended attributes.
Neither ext4 nor tempfs support this. XFS is recommended.

So why all the SkipTests? Why not simply raise an error? We still need
the tests to run on the base image for OpenStack's CI system. Since
we were previously mocking out xattr, there wasn't a problem, but we
also weren't actually testing anything. This patch adds functionality
to validate xattr data, so we need to drop the mock.

`test.unit.skip_if_no_xattrs()` is also imported into `test.functional`
so that functional tests can import it from the functional test
namespace.

The related OpenStack CI infrastructure changes are made in
https://review.openstack.org/#/c/394600/.

Co-Authored-By: John Dickinson <me@not.mn>

Change-Id: I98a37c0d451f4960b7a12f648e4405c6c6716808
2017-11-03 13:30:05 -04:00

9.3 KiB

Development Guidelines

Coding Guidelines

For the most part we try to follow PEP 8 guidelines which can be viewed here: http://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0008/

Testing Guidelines

Swift has a comprehensive suite of tests and pep8 checks that are run on all submitted code, and it is recommended that developers execute the tests themselves to catch regressions early. Developers are also expected to keep the test suite up-to-date with any submitted code changes.

Swift's tests and pep8 checks can be executed in an isolated environment with tox: http://tox.testrun.org/

To execute the tests:

  • Ensure pip and virtualenv are upgraded to satisfy the version requirements listed in the OpenStack global requirements:

    pip install pip -U
    pip install virtualenv -U
  • Install tox:

    pip install tox
  • Generate list of distribution packages to install for testing:

    tox -e bindep

    Now install these packages using your distribution package manager like apt-get, dnf, yum, or zypper.

  • Run tox from the root of the swift repo:

    tox

Note

If you installed using cd ~/swift; sudo python setup.py develop, you may need to do cd ~/swift; sudo chown -R ${USER}:${USER} swift.egg-info prior to running tox.

  • By default tox will run all of the unit test and pep8 checks listed in the tox.ini file envlist option. A subset of the test environments can be specified on the tox command line or by setting the TOXENV environment variable. For example, to run only the pep8 checks and python2.7 unit tests use:

    tox -e pep8,py27

    or:

    TOXENV=py27,pep8 tox

Note

As of tox version 2.0.0, most environment variables are not automatically passed to the test environment. Swift's tox.ini overrides this default behavior so that variable names matching SWIFT_* and *_proxy will be passed, but you may need to run tox --recreate for this to take effect after upgrading from tox <2.0.0.

Conversely, if you do not want those environment variables to be passed to the test environment then you will need to unset them before calling tox.

Also, if you ever encounter DistributionNotFound, try to use tox --recreate or remove the .tox directory to force tox to recreate the dependency list.

Swift's tests require having an XFS directory available in /tmp or in the TMPDIR environment variable.

Swift's functional tests may be executed against a development_saio or other running Swift cluster using the command:

tox -e func

The endpoint and authorization credentials to be used by functional tests should be configured in the test.conf file as described in the section setup_scripts.

The environment variable SWIFT_TEST_POLICY may be set to specify a particular storage policy name that will be used for testing. When set, tests that would otherwise not specify a policy or choose a random policy from those available will instead use the policy specified. Tests that use more than one policy will include the specified policy in the set of policies used. The specified policy must be available on the cluster under test.

For example, this command would run the functional tests using policy 'silver':

SWIFT_TEST_POLICY=silver tox -e func

To run a single functional test, use the --no-discover option together with a path to a specific test method, for example:

tox -e func -- --no-discover test.functional.tests.TestFile.testCopy

In-process functional testing

If the test.conf file is not found then the functional test framework will instantiate a set of Swift servers in the same process that executes the functional tests. This 'in-process test' mode may also be enabled (or disabled) by setting the environment variable SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS to a true (or false) value prior to executing tox -e func.

When using the 'in-process test' mode some server configuration options may be set using environment variables:

  • the optional in-memory object server may be selected by setting the environment variable SWIFT_TEST_IN_MEMORY_OBJ to a true value.
  • encryption may be added to the proxy pipeline by setting the environment variable SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS_CONF_LOADER to encryption.
  • a 2+1 EC policy may be installed as the default policy by setting the environment variable SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS_CONF_LOADER to ec.
  • logging to stdout may be enabled by setting SWIFT_TEST_DEBUG_LOGS.

For example, this command would run the in-process mode functional tests with encryption enabled in the proxy-server:

SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS=1 SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS_CONF_LOADER=encryption \
    tox -e func

This particular example may also be run using the func-encryption tox environment:

tox -e func-encryption

The tox.ini file also specifies test environments for running other in-process functional test configurations, e.g.:

tox -e func-ec

To debug the functional tests, use the 'in-process test' mode and pass the --pdb flag to tox:

SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS=1 tox -e func -- --pdb \
    test.functional.tests.TestFile.testCopy

The 'in-process test' mode searches for proxy-server.conf and swift.conf config files from which it copies config options and overrides some options to suit in process testing. The search will first look for config files in a <custom_conf_source_dir> that may optionally be specified using the environment variable:

SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS_CONF_DIR=<custom_conf_source_dir>

If SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS_CONF_DIR is not set, or if a config file is not found in <custom_conf_source_dir>, the search will then look in the etc/ directory in the source tree. If the config file is still not found, the corresponding sample config file from etc/ is used (e.g. proxy-server.conf-sample or swift.conf-sample).

When using the 'in-process test' mode SWIFT_TEST_POLICY may be set to specify a particular storage policy name that will be used for testing as described above. When set, this policy must exist in the swift.conf file and its corresponding ring file must exist in <custom_conf_source_dir> (if specified) or etc/. The test setup will set the specified policy to be the default and use its ring file properties for constructing the test object ring. This allows in-process testing to be run against various policy types and ring files.

For example, this command would run the in-process mode functional tests using config files found in $HOME/my_tests and policy 'silver':

SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS=1 SWIFT_TEST_IN_PROCESS_CONF_DIR=$HOME/my_tests \
   SWIFT_TEST_POLICY=silver tox -e func

Coding Style

Swift uses flake8 with the OpenStack hacking module to enforce coding style.

Install flake8 and hacking with pip or by the packages of your Operating System.

It is advised to integrate flake8+hacking with your editor to get it automated and not get caught by Jenkins.

For example for Vim the syntastic plugin can do this for you.

Documentation Guidelines

The documentation in docstrings should follow the PEP 257 conventions (as mentioned in the PEP 8 guidelines).

More specifically:

  1. Triple quotes should be used for all docstrings.
  2. If the docstring is simple and fits on one line, then just use one line.
  3. For docstrings that take multiple lines, there should be a newline after the opening quotes, and before the closing quotes.
  4. Sphinx is used to build documentation, so use the restructured text markup to designate parameters, return values, etc. Documentation on the sphinx specific markup can be found here: http://sphinx.pocoo.org/markup/index.html

Installing Sphinx:

  1. Install sphinx (On Ubuntu: sudo apt-get install python-sphinx)
  2. python setup.py build_sphinx

Manpages

For sanity check of your change in manpage, use this command in the root of your Swift repo:

./.manpages

You can have the following copyright and license statement at the top of each source file. Copyright assignment is optional.

New files should contain the current year. Substantial updates can have another year added, and date ranges are not needed.:

# Copyright (c) 2013 OpenStack Foundation.
#
# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
# you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
# You may obtain a copy of the License at
#
#    http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
#
# Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
# distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or
# implied.
# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
# limitations under the License.